Efficiency, Legitimacy, and Impacts of Targeting Methods: Evidence from an Experiment in Niger
No ObtainPoverty ReductionNov 2021
The approaches to choose protection web beneficiaries are the topic of regular debates. Concentrating on assessments ordinarily concentration on efficiency by documenting the pre-plan profile of picked beneficiaries. This review presents a additional in depth examination of focusing on performance via an experiment embedded in a nationwide hard cash transfer plan in Niger. Eligible villages ended up randomly assigned to have beneficiary households picked by local community-centered focusing on (CBT), proxy-means screening (PMT), or a method to recognize the food items-insecure (FCS). The review considers focusing on legitimacy and the affect of focusing on option on plan success centered on data gathered just after plan roll-out. PMT is additional efficient in determining households with reduced use per capita. Nonbeneficiaries uncover method-centered approaches (PMT and FCS) additional respectable than CBT. Manipulation and facts imperfections affect CBT, which can describe why it is not the most respectable. Application impacts on some welfare proportions are much larger amid households picked by PMT than CBT.
References
- 2012. “Concentrating on the Lousy: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Indonesia.” American Economic Evaluation 102 (four): 1206–40. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2019. “Does Elite Capture Make any difference? Regional Elites and Targeted Welfare Programs in Indonesia.” AEA Papers and Proceedings 109: 334–39. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2016a. “Community Construction and the Aggregation of Information: Idea and Evidence from Indonesia.” American Economic Evaluation 106 (seven): 1663–704. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2016b. “Self-Concentrating on: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Indonesia.” Journal of Political Economy 124 (two): 371–427. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2018. “Obtaining the Lousy vs. Measuring Their Poverty: Exploring the Drivers of Concentrating on Efficiency in Indonesia.” Earth Bank Economic Evaluation 33 (3): 573–97. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 2019. “Universal Simple Money in the Developing Earth.” Yearly Evaluation of Economics eleven (1): 959–83. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2000. “Capture and Governance at Regional and Countrywide Degrees.” American Economic Evaluation ninety (two): 135–39. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2019. “Decentralization and Performance of Subsidy Concentrating on: Evidence from Chiefs in Rural Malawi.” Journal of Community Economics 185: 1–25. Google Scholar .
- 2020. “Food Protection Steps in Sub-Saharan Africa. A Validation of the LSMS-ISA Scale.” Journal of African Economies 29 (1): 90–120. Google Scholar .
- 2019. “Promoting Successful Inclusion and Resilience amid the Lousy: Multi-nation RCT of the Sahel Adaptive Social Protection Application.” AEA RCT Registry. Google Scholar .
- 2018. “A Lousy Indicates Check? Econometric Concentrating on in Africa.” Journal of Enhancement Economics 134: 109–24. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2014. “Validity and Reliability of Food Protection Steps.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1331 (1): 230–48. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2004a. Concentrating on of Transfers in Developing Nations around the world: Evaluation of Lessons and Practical experience. Vol. 1. Washington, DC: Earth Bank Publications. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 2004b. “Concentrating on Results Redux.” Earth Bank Analysis Observer 19 (1): 61–85. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 2004. “On the Concentrating on and Redistributive Efficiencies of Alternate Transfer Instruments.” Evaluation of Money and Wealth fifty (1): 11–27. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2002. “Community-Based Concentrating on Mechanisms for Social Basic safety Nets: A Crucial Evaluation.” Earth Enhancement thirty (3): 375–94. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2015. Basic safety Nets in Africa: Powerful Mechanisms to Arrive at the Lousy and Most Vulnerable. Washington, DC: Earth Bank and Agence Française de Développement. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 2017. “The Concentrating on Efficiency of Social Transfers.” Journal of Enhancement Efficiency nine (two): 162–211. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2020. Exploring Universal Simple Money: A Tutorial to Navigating Principles, Evidence, and Tactics. Washington, DC: Earth Bank. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 1995. “Proxy Indicates Exams for Concentrating on Social Programs.” Doing work Paper 118, Dwelling Standards Measurement Review, Earth Bank. Washington, DC, Usa. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 2018. “Universal Simple Incomes vs . Targeted Transfers: Anti-Poverty Programs in Developing Nations around the world.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 32 (four): 201–26. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2019. “Concentrating on Ultra-poor Homes in Honduras and Peru.” Earth Bank Economic Evaluation 33 (1): 63–94. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 2016. “How Narrowly Need to Anti-poverty Programs Be Targeted? Simulation Evidence from Bolivia and Indonesia.” Dialogue Paper Series No. 213, Göttingen University. Göttingen, Germany. Google Scholar .
- 2016. “Retooling Poverty Concentrating on Applying Out-of-Sample Validation and Machine Studying.” Earth Bank Economic Evaluation 32 (3): 531–50. Google Scholar .
- 2013. “Community-Based Concentrating on in the Social Protection Sector.” Doing work Paper No. 514, Abroad Enhancement Institute, London, United kingdom. Google Scholar
- 2012. “Outside of Baseline and Stick to-Up: The Situation for A lot more T in Experiments.” Journal of Enhancement Economics ninety nine (two): 210–21. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
- 2012. “Who is Vouching for the Input Voucher? Decentralized Concentrating on and Elite Capture in Tanzania.” Earth Enhancement forty (8): 1619–33. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2020. “Behavioral Alter Marketing, Dollars Transfers and Early Childhood Enhancement, Experimental Evidence from a Governing administration Application in a Very low-revenue Environment.” Earth Bank Coverage Analysis Doing work Paper No. 9368, Earth Bank: Washington, DC, Usa. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 1995. “Is Concentrating on Via a Function Requirement Successful? Some Evidence for Rural India.” In Community Investing and the Lousy: Idea and Evidence. Edited by Dominique van de Walle and Kimberly Nead, 413–44. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Push. Google Scholar .
- 2009. “How Relevant is Concentrating on to the Achievements of an Antipoverty Application?” Earth Bank Analysis Observer 24 (two): 205–31. LinkGoogle Scholar .
- 2019. “How to Goal Homes in Adaptive Social Protection Techniques? Evidence from Humanitarian and Enhancement Ways in Niger.” Journal of Enhancement Reports fifty five (sup1): 75–90. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2016. “Reaching the Lousy: Dollars Transfer Application Concentrating on in Cameroon.” Earth Enhancement 83: 244–63. CrossrefGoogle Scholar .
- 2020. “Lousy Households’ Successful Investments of Dollars Transfers: Quasi-Experimental Evidence from Niger.” Journal of African Economies 29 (1): 63–89. Google Scholar .
- 2009. “Validating the Earth Food Programme’s Food Use Rating and Alternate Indicators of Home Food Protection.” Dialogue Paper 00870, Global Food Coverage Analysis Institute, Washington, DC, Usa. Google Scholar .
Earth Bank . 2011. “Niger Basic safety Net Task, Task Appraisal Document.” Earth Bank, Washington, DC, Usa. Google ScholarEarth Bank . 2017. “Republic of Niger. Priorities for Ending Poverty and Boosting Shared Prosperity. Systematic Place Diagnostic.” Earth Bank, Washington, DC, Usa. LinkGoogle ScholarEarth Food Programme . 2008. “Food Use Assessment: Calculation and Use of the Food Use Rating in Food Use and Food Protection Assessment.” Specialized Assistance Sheet, Rome. Google Scholar- 1998. “Nonparametric Regression Approaches in Economics.” Journal of Economic Literature 36 (two): 669–721. Google Scholar .